Preparing a Proposal
Proposal Review Process
Department
Typically, while constructing a proposal, the PI consults the department head or Laboratory director regarding the availability and use of space and personnel and secures his/her approval. If the research involves human subjects, animal subjects, or hazardous substances, approval of the relevant committees must also be obtained prior to submission to the Dean or his/her designee.
Dean
The Dean or designee reviews and approves the proposal and forwards it to the appropriate pre-award office with the following:
Pre-Award Offices
Proposals should be submitted three (non-federal) or five (federal) business days in advance of the sponsor's deadline for the final institutional review for conformance with University and sponsor requirements.
Proposals to federal, state, and the majority of other sponsors must always be signed by an authorized institutional representative. Each pre-award office has individuals so designated.
Some things to remember when assembling and then submitting a proposal ...
Last updated: 11/14/2008
The Harvard University Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations generates support for major institutional priorities by building and sustaining partnerships with major corporations and foundations.
The mission of the Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations is to be of service to the Offices of the President and Provost, the leadership of the College and the Harvard graduate and professional Schools, faculty members, senior administrators, and development colleagues, to maximize the breadth and quality of these alliances. They aspire to be a center of expertise at Harvard on private foundation philanthropy and corporate giving.
The following is a list of the coordinated prospects for Harvard University, managed at the University level by the Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations. Of the 66,000+ foundations in the US, the Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations has carefully selected a small number of organizations with whom the University has pre-existing relationships, or has the opportunity to develop a robust institutional relationship, recognizing that many of these entities have multiple points of contact across the landscape of the University. The Provost asks that the Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations be aware of any contact with these entities; in turn, they ask that interested parties alert them before submitting a proposal to these entities.
Please include the following information:
Finally, there are a number of foundations and corporations that accept only a single proposal per institution per grant making cycle. The Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations works in conjunction with the office of the Provost on these invitational competitions, and asks that faculty please coordinate the submission of proposals through that process. The number for the Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations is (617) 495-8861.
Email contacts:
April Edrington, Deputy Director,
Beccah Wells, Coordinator,
University Managed Prospects
* indicates proposals must be coordinated through Office of the Provost
**indicates proposals must be coordinated through Office of Corporate and Foundation Relations
| Foundations: | Corporations: |
| Aga Khan Foundation | Agilent Technologies |
| Atlantic Philanthropies | Apple Computer |
| Arcadia Trust (Lisbet Rausing) | Bank of America |
| Barr Foundation | Barclays Bank |
| Boston Foundation | Bausch & Lomb |
| Bradley Foundation, Lynde & Harry | BP |
| Broad Foundation | Chevron |
| Buffett Early Childhood Fund | Cisco Systems |
| Cabot Family Trust | Citigroup |
| Carnegie Corporation Of New York | Corning |
| Casey Foundation, Annie E. | Dell Corporation |
| Coca Cola, Inc. & Foundation | Deutsche Bank |
| Commonwealth Fund | EDAX |
| Cummings Foundation, Nathan | EISAI |
| Davis Foundation, Arthur Vining | EMC |
| Dell Foundation, Michael and Susan | Exxon Mobil |
| Duke Foundation, Doris | |
| **Fidelity Foundation | FAMRI |
| Ford Foundation | Fedex |
| Fox Foundation, Michael J. | Genentech |
| Gates Foundation | General Electric |
| Goldman Sachs Foundation | Google, Inc. |
| Google.Org | Hewlett Packard, Inc. |
| Hearst Foundation | IBM |
| Hewlett Foundation, William & Flora | Intel |
| Higgins Trust, Eugene | Lenovo |
| Humanity United | L’Oreal |
| IBM International Foundation | Merck |
| Infosys | Microsoft |
| Intel Foundation | Novartis |
| Johnson Foundation, Robert Wood | Nvidia |
| Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation | Pfizer |
| Kaiser Family Foundation, Betty and George | Raytheon |
| Kavli Foundation | Schlumberger |
| *Keck Foundation | Siemens |
| Kellogg Foundation, W.K. | Sun Microsystems |
| Kresge Foundation | Time Warner |
| ** Levy Foundation, Leon | Toshiba |
| Li Ka-Shing Foundation | Varian Semiconductor |
| Luce Foundation, Henry | Yahoo! |
| MacArthur Foundation, John D. & Catherine T. | Zeiss |
| McKnight Endowment Fund for Neuroscience | |
| McKnight (Evelyn F.) Brain Research Foundation | |
| McKnight Foundation | |
| Medtronic Foundation | |
| Mellon Foundation | |
| Metlife Foundation | |
| Moore Foundation, Gordon & Betty | |
| Mott Foundation, Charles Stewart | |
| Norlien Foundation | |
| Omidyar Networks | |
| Open Society Institute | |
| Oracle | |
| Packard Foundation, David & Lucile | |
| Petrie Foundation, Carroll & Milton | |
| Prince of Wales | |
| Ramussen Foundation, V. Kann | |
| Rausing Trust, Sigrid | |
| RIKEN | |
| Rockefeller Brothers Fund | |
| Rockefeller Foundation | |
| Sloan Foundation | |
| Smith Family Foundation, Richard & Susan | |
| Starr Foundation | |
| Starr International | |
| Surdna Foundation | |
| Teagle Foundation | |
| Templeton Foundation, John | |
| Wal-Mart Foundation | |
| Walton Family Foundation | |
Submit the completed proposal three business days for non-federal sponsors and five business days for federal sponsors prior to deadline.
If a proposal is in response to an RFP or solicitation, please forward the announcement (or URL of the applicable Web site) to your pre-award along with the completed proposal. On occasion an RFP may include terms and conditions that conflict with Harvard's research policies, and additional time may be needed to resolve/negotiate any issues.
Proposal Submission, Minimum Information Requirements
Checklist of data elements required on Dean's cover sheet
| Date submitted to OSP | |
| Sponsor deadline -- indicate postmark or receipt; please indicate whether already issued to sponsor | |
| Delivery instructions -- mailing method and number of copies | |
| PI name/Co-PI/Fellow name/Department | |
| PI/Co-PI appointment -- where applicable: no time limit or end date | |
| Administrative contact for PI - with pertinent contact information | |
| Title of proposal | |
| Sponsor name/address (including fax and email)/Contact name | |
| Award/Fund # (if known) | |
| Subcontract proposal/name of prime | |
| Project period | |
| Amount (all years) | |
| Status indication -- New/Renewal/Continuation/Supplement/Revision/No-cost extension/Other | |
| Proposal type -- Research/Instruction/Other sponsored activity/Financial Aid/Fellowship | |
| Location -- On-campus/Off-campus | |
| Tub and org | |
| Fringe benefit rates -- please indicate all that apply for each applicable year | |
| F&A rate -- please indicate which rate applies |
Separate Forms and Approvals Attached to Dean's Approval Form - where applicable
| Checklist for administrative/clerical staff directly charged to federal award | |
| Subcontract (attach scope, budget, basis for selection, and proposal/approval from subcontract institution) | |
| Human Subjects Approval/Training Certification | |
| Animal Approval | |
| Financial Conflict of Interest forms | |
| Cost-sharing documentation | |
| University Development Office Approval | |
| Biohazards Approval | |
| Multiple Schools |
OSP Review of Terms and Conditions
Before accepting an award on behalf of the University, OSP / HMS-SPA / SPH-OFS reviews all terms and conditions, regardless of the sponsor, and is responsible for negotiating appropriate remedies if an award fits into one of the following categories:
In the case of all industry awards or other awards with non-standard patent, copyright or licensing terms, the University Office for Technology Development must also approve the award terms. This approval is coordinated by your pre-award office.
Action Memo
When the Notice of Grant Award and related terms and conditions are accepted by the pre-award office, the account activating the award is set up in the system and an action memo is generated, displaying the account values representing this award.
The PI receives an action memo, detailing the account number and award dates and dollars, when a sponsoring agency grants a new, or renewal, award. This award must
Participation Agreement
The Participation Agreement must be signed before an award becomes effective.
It is the responsibility of the PI to obtain Participation Agreements from anyone else pursing the scientific or technical aspects of the research.
The following approvals and certifications may be or are required with each proposal submission. Please review the details of each before submitting your proposal to the applicable pre-award office for review.
Human Subjects in Research
All research using human subjects must be reviewed or designated as exempt from review by a Harvard Institutional Review Board (IRB). Currently, there are three IRBs: one each in SPH, HMS and FAS, with the FAS IRB providing oversight for human subject research at University area schools and affiliates.
Each IRB has established its own policies and procedures. See below for links to IRB sites.
School/Tub |
Policies/Procedures |
Location |
| FAS | Use of Human Subjects in Research | http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~research/ hum_sub/index.html |
| FAS | Statement of Policies and Procedures Governing the Use of Human Subjects in Research at Harvard University | http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~research/ greybook/humsubs.html |
| SPH | Human Subjects Committee | http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hsc/ |
| SPH | Federal wide Assurance of Compliance with DHHS Regulations for Protection of Human Research Subjects | http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/humansubjects/ assurance/filasurt.htm |
| HMS | HMS/HSDM Committee on Human Studies | http://www.hms.harvard.edu/orsp /human/human.html |
| HMS | Guidelines for Investigators in Scientific Research | http://www.hms.harvard.edu/ integrity/scientif.html |
Typically, a sponsor requires that proposed studies with human subjects be approved by the requisite IRB at the time the award is made. Some require that this approval be in hand at the time a proposal is submitted or, at a minimum, in process. Prior to submitting a proposal one should review the sponsor's human subject requirements. This information is generally available on the sponsor's web site or in the RFP.
The NIH requires that all key personnel working on human subjects studies complete training. The SPH and HMS extended this requirement to all personnel involved in human subject study design, execution or interpretation, regardless of funding source.
Harvard has created HETHR: Harvard Ethics Training in Human Research, for use in satisfying the training requirement. HETHR, an interactive online training program, is also available to outside collaborators on Harvard projects, as well as to the general public, free of charge.
For more information on the NIH requirement, Harvard policy and access to the University's online training program:
Link to General FAQ about the Human Subject Training
Requirement
Link to HETHR Training
Use of Animals in Research
All use of animals in research or teaching must be reviewed and approved by the appropriate animal committee. Currently there are two committees, one for the University area, and one for the Longwood area.
Typically, a sponsor requires that proposed studies with animals be approved by the appropriate committee at the time the award is made. However, some may require the approval at the time of proposal submission. Please review the individual sponsor requirement prior to submitting a proposal.
Use the following links for information on procedures, guidelines, and forms:
School/Tub |
Policy |
Location |
| University area | Use of Animals in Research and Teaching | http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~research/approvals/iacuc.html |
| HMS/HSPH/HSDM | Standing Committee on Animals | http://www.hms.harvard.edu/orsp/animal.html |
All research using human subjects must be reviewed or designated as exempt from review by a Harvard Institutional Review Board (IRB). Currently, there are three IRBs: one each in SPH, HMS and FAS, with the FAS IRB providing oversight for human subject research at University area schools and affiliates.
Biohazardous Materials
In keeping with Federal regulations, before a scientific project can begin, the laboratory must be "certified" to work with radioactive materials, recombinant DNA, infectious agents and/or select agents. Some sponsors require a copy of an environmental health and safety approval letter signed by an authorized institutional official or head of the University's Environmental Health and Safety Department. Other sponsors may require that the PI complete a checklist.
Please refer to links below for more information.
School/Tub |
Policy |
Location |
| University - wide | Use of Hazardous Biological Agents | http://www.hms.harvard.edu/orsp/coms/IBC/COMS-1977-1978.pdf |
| University - wide | Committee on Microbiological Safety, Office of Research Protection | http://www.hms.harvard.edu/orsp/coms/ |
Conflict of Interest
Both the NIH and the NSF require that the Principal Investigator and other project staff disclose any significant financial interests (salary, stocks, royalty income, etc.) that could appear to affect their research.
Each school within the University has established a Conflict of Interest disclosure policy and procedure to meet these regulatory requirements, in addition to the University's own Conflict of Interest policies.
At the proposal stage PIs are required to certify that
For specific school requirements and forms, refer to the links below. If your school /program is not listed, please contact your Dean or Director's office for guidance.
School/Tub |
Policy |
Location |
| FAS | Conflict of Interest and Conflict of Commitment
|
http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~research/policy/coi.html |
| KSG | Conflict of Interest Disclosure Form
|
http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/research/conflict_of_interest_form.doc |
| HGSE | Conflict of Interest Disclosure Form(federal proposals)
|
Click here to download |
| HMS/HSDM | Policy of Conflict of Interest and Commitment | http://www.hms.harvard.edu/integrity/conf.html |
| SPH | HSPH Faculty Handbook | http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/facultyhandbook/ |
Additional information is available from the Office of Technology Development (OTD):
School/Tub |
Policy |
Location |
| OTD | Harvard Policies - Conflict of Interest | http://www.otd.harvard.edu/resources/policies/#conflict |
The President and Fellows of Harvard College adopted the Statement of Policy in Regard to Intellectual Property, on February 4, 2008. This Policy, as it may be amended from time to time, applies to all members of the University and visitors who perform research in Harvard facilities. Also, Federal policy requires the University to obtain written agreements from anyone performing research under a federally sponsored program regarding their obligations for reporting and assignment of inventions.
Each person performing research at Harvard should sign either the Harvard University Participation Agreement or the Harvard University Visitor Participation Agreement as applicable.
Go to the Participation Agreement.
Go to the Visitor Participation Agreement.
SPONSOR'S SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS
Subcontracting Report for Individual Contracts-SF294
(WOSB), HUBZone Small Business (HUBZone SB), Veteran-Owned Small Business (VOSB) and Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Small
Business concerns under a subcontracting plan. For the Department of Defense (DOD), the National Aeronautics and Space Administration
(NASA), and the Coast Guard, this form also collects subcontract award data for Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) and Minority Institutions (MIs).
Minority Business Enterprises/Women-owned Business Enterprises Utilization Report
MBE/WBE utilization is based on Executive Orders 11625, 12138, 12432, P.L. 102-389 and EPA Regulations Part 30 and 31. EPA Form 5700-52A must be completed by recipients of Federal grants, cooperative agreements, or other Federal financial assistance which involve procurement of supplies, equipment, construction or services to accomplish Federal assistance programs.
Recipients are required to report 30 days after the end of each federal fiscal quarter or annually, per the terms and conditions of the financial assistance agreement. Submission dates are January 30, April 30, July 30, and October 30. The submission date for annual reports is October 30. MBE/WBE program requirements, including reporting, are material terms and conditions of the financial assistance agreement.